I'm basically the same size as you boarda and had the same problem. Wide boards are too wide, and regular boards are too thin. Luckily some companies do make mid-wide boards. I picked up a Burton Triumph last season which fits my boots perfectly (and rules). Unfortunately, they stopped selling them this season. 🙁 However, your local snowboarding shop may still have some leftover from last year. Also, I've previously ridden a K2 Illusion mid-wide and that was one of the best boards I ever had. Unfortunately, too many off-trail runs (and trees) busted it up pretty badly.If it's not too late to do a return, you could look into mid-wide options.